- 1930's: Consensus: Bobby Jones Actual: Gene Sarazen (4)
- 1940's: Consensus: Ben Hogan Actual: Sam Snead (4)
- 1950's: Consensus: Sam Snead Actual: Ben Hogan (6)
- 1960's: Consensus: Arnold Palmer Actual: Jack Nicklaus (7)
- 1970's: Consensus: Jack Nicklaus Actual: Jack Nicklaus (8)
- 1980's: Consensus: Jack Nicklaus Actual: Tom Watson (5)
- 1990's: Consensus: Tiger Woods Actual: Nick Faldo (4)
- 2000's: Consensus: Tiger Woods Actual: Tiger Woods (10)
Pretty interesting that the '70's and the '00's (Jack's 8 and Tiger's 10) were the only decades that the consensus was correct on. Also noteworthy is the "flip flop" of Hogan and Snead in the '40's and 50's - reflecting that Hogan's prowess in Majors came rather late in his career. When I asked the group about this, most of them did not think of Snead and Hogan as peers, believing that Snead played a bit later than Hogan.